A Detroit meatpacker, a ballpark contract and a sausage maker’s recipe.

Ball Park is an American hot dog brand, and Tyson Foods has owned it since 2014. Its story begins not in a test kitchen but at a baseball stadium: the franks were originally made for the Detroit Tigers by Hygrade Food Products, a Detroit-based meatpacking company, and only afterwards sold to shoppers.

The year the hot dog was created depends on the account. The Detroit Free Press columnist Tom Walsh, writing on 2 November 2014 about a memoir by the former Hygrade executive Clyde Riley, said the Ball Park hot dog was created in 1957 to boost sales to fans at Tiger Stadium. The brand’s own history gives the same year, saying that in 1957 Hygrade signed on as the sole supplier of hot dogs for the Tigers. Michigan Public Radio, in a piece dated 12 February 2014, and the Detroit historian Richard Bak, writing for the Vintage Detroit Collection on 25 June 2012, both put the start in 1958, when, Bak says, the club had become dissatisfied with its previous vendor.

Walsh described how the contract came about. In the mid-1950s, he wrote, Jim Campbell, then a Tigers front-office manager and later the club’s president, was looking for a new hot dog supplier, and Hygrade’s president, Hugo Slotkin, believed the company could gain prestige by making the dogs that Tigers fans ate. Slotkin asked his chief sausage maker, Gus Hauff, to create a new hot dog. Hauff, Walsh wrote, added veal to the recipe, and the company made the franks larger than before. Bak, who spells the name Hauf and calls him a sausage superintendent, says the formula remains a secret.

The fans liked the result. Bak writes that in 1959 the hot dogs became the official hot dog of Briggs Stadium, as Tiger Stadium was then called. The next step, Walsh wrote, was to give the product a name and sell it in grocery stores at a premium.

Who chose the name is also told two ways. Walsh, following Riley’s memoir, credits the salesman Bill Willtsie, who came up with “Ball Park Franks” at a weekend Hygrade brainstorming meeting; the brand’s own history likewise mentions a weekend brainstorming session. Michigan Public Radio credits a Hygrade co-worker, Mary Ann Kirk, and Bak, spelling her name Kurk, says she won a prize for the winning name. The company says that by 1959 the newly named Ball Park franks were in grocery stores across Detroit.

Hygrade, Sara Lee, Hillshire Brands and Tyson.

For three decades Ball Park stayed with the Detroit company that created it. Clyde Riley, the subject of Walsh’s 2014 column, had joined Hygrade through its purchase of the Indianapolis meat company Kingan & Co., where he had worked at a slaughterhouse in Dothan, Alabama. Walsh wrote that Riley was a young middle manager when the Tiger Stadium opportunity arose, that by the mid-1960s he was Hygrade’s Michigan sales manager, and that he became president of Hygrade in 1975.

The company changed hands at the end of the 1980s. In 1989, Walsh wrote, Riley helped arrange the sale of Hygrade to the food group Sara Lee, the company behind the Sara Lee cheesecake brand. English Wikipedia adds that Sara Lee bought Hygrade from Hanson Industries. According to Walsh, Sara Lee was interested chiefly in the Ball Park brand and later dismantled Hygrade’s older meatpacking operations; Riley stayed on in a largely ceremonial role for several years before retiring.

Sara Lee then reshaped itself. Walsh noted that Sara Lee split itself in two in 2012 and that Ball Park franks were then sold under the umbrella of Hillshire Brands, the meat business that kept brands such as Hillshire Farm and Jimmy Dean.

Hillshire Brands did not stay independent for long. Talk Business & Politics reported that Tyson Foods completed its acquisition of Hillshire Brands on 28 August 2014. Tyson’s chief executive, Donnie Smith, said in a statement quoted in that report that part of the company’s strategic plan had been to shift toward higher-margin prepared and branded foods. The same report said Andy Callahan, formerly president of Hillshire’s retail business, would manage the retail consumer brands, among them Jimmy Dean, Ball Park, Hillshire Farm and Sara Lee.

Under Tyson the brand has kept adding products around its stadium theme. Meat+Poultry reported on 7 April 2021, from Tyson’s home base of Springdale, Arkansas, that Ball Park had launched Fully Loaded Nacho Cheese Franks, timed to the start of the baseball season. The magazine quoted Amy Margolin, a brand manager on Ball Park, describing the product as bringing together two summer flavours in one bite. Today the brand’s website groups its range into two families, hot dogs and patties, and says it is loading the grill with more than just hot dogs.

Design and documentation.

The brands in this group sell hot dogs, sausages, sliced deli meats and breakfast meats, foods that are bought chilled or frozen and are often chosen quickly from a long refrigerated case. Packaging in this category has to work at a glance: a name, a colour and a picture of the food have to be legible through clear film or on a small carton, under bright supermarket lighting, next to many similar packs.

That is why identity in this part of the grocery trade tends to rest on a few repeated signals rather than on a single container. A wordmark, a founder’s name, a slogan, a mascot or a jingle can travel across packs, advertising and sponsorships, while the pack itself changes size and format many times over the decades.

The companies behind these names have often changed hands, merged their factories or moved production, so each guide asks plain questions: who started the brand, who owns it now, where its meat is processed and how its look has been presented. Each separates what independent sources record from what a company says about itself.

A Detroit agency, a sausage maker’s answer and a line that stuck.

A central piece of Ball Park’s identity is a sentence rather than a picture. Walsh’s 2014 column tells how it was found. By the mid-1960s, he wrote, sales were booming locally, and the Detroit broadcaster Sonny Eliot was pitching Ball Park and other Hygrade products on the airwaves. In 1965, Riley and Slotkin asked the advertising agency W.B. Doner to come up with a strategy to take the brand national.

Doner wanted a catchphrase, Walsh wrote, something that explained why shoppers should pay extra for these hot dogs rather than a rival’s. Gus Hauff talked about beef trimmings and a leaner veal emulsion, which offered nothing for a jingle. When a Doner executive pressed him on why the Tigers had chosen his hot dog, Hauff blurted out the answer: “Because they plump when you cook them.” The agency built the national campaign on that line. Wikipedia also credits the tagline to the W.B. Doner agency in 1965 and dates the national launch to the same year.

The line is still part of the brand. On its website today Ball Park writes the promise in a looser, spoken form, “Plump when you cook ’em,” marked as a registered trademark, and says that within a decade of the Tiger Stadium deal the franks had gone national behind it. The same site keeps returning to baseball and summer, describing its hot dogs as a summer tradition alongside a trip to the ballpark or fireworks on the Fourth of July.

The stadium connection also supplies the brand with its lore. Bak recounts a story from the 1960s in which the Tigers player Gates Brown was on the bench eating a hot dog when he was suddenly called on to pinch hit; he stuffed it under his shirt, hit the ball to the outfield and, after sliding into second base, came up with a mustard stain across his uniform. Bak also notes that vendors still sell Ball Park franks at Comerica Park, the Tigers’ current home, keeping a Detroit tradition going.

For a design guide, Ball Park shows how a brand can be anchored in a place and a promise: a named stadium, a meatpacker’s home city and one plain sentence about what happens in the pan. The verbal identity — “they plump when you cook them” — has outlived the company that commissioned it and the stadium that inspired it. Compare it with the Brooklyn-born Nathan’s Famous and with Hillshire Farm, which passed through the same Sara Lee and Tyson ownership. For this guide we use stadium navy, scoreboard red and mustard with a heavy sans, an unofficial interpretation; no product or logo is reproduced.

Keep Ball Park’s identity on hand — save it to a board in the Made Good inspiration library.