Elbridge Ayer Burbank is worth studying less for any single picture than for the discipline of the whole body of work. Faced with a long list of sitters, he settled on a handful of small, consistent formats and returned to them again and again. A designer building a campaign, a book series or a set of brand illustrations faces the same problem: how do you make a hundred things feel related without making them dull? His portraits offer a practical answer, and they also carry a responsibility, because the subjects were real people recorded in a particular historical moment.
The works discussed here are held by the Art Institute of Chicago and, in much larger numbers, by the Newberry Library in Chicago. The Art Institute’s collection data does not flag the Burbank paintings it holds as public domain, so this guide describes them in text rather than reproducing them, and nothing here implies that they are free to use. For public domain images you can reuse, browse the MGD museum inspiration collection.
Who was Elbridge Ayer Burbank?
The Art Institute of Chicago records him as an American artist, 1858–1949. Biographies agree that he was born in Harvard, Illinois; they differ on the day, with the Illinois Historical Art Project and several other biographies giving 10 August 1858 and others giving 10 April, so this guide gives only the year. Published biographies, including the Illinois Historical Art Project, say he began art study at the Chicago Academy of Design, the school that later became the Art Institute of Chicago, in 1874, at sixteen.
Several biographies place him in Munich between 1886 and 1891, a period when many American painters studied there. Accounts mention friendships with the painters Joseph Henry Sharp, William R. Leigh and Toby Rosenthal, and one biography names Paul Nauen and Frederick Fehr as his teachers. Because the accounts differ on exact dates and teachers, treat the details as outline rather than record. If you want a Munich-trained American contemporary who later worked in the Southwest, see our profile of Joseph Henry Sharp.
Archive listings connected with the Newberry Library describe his early subjects as mainly African American sitters before 1897. He later settled on the West Coast; biographies place his last years in San Francisco, where he died in 1949.
The Ayer commission, 1897
The turning point in nearly every account is 1897. His uncle, Edward E. Ayer, a collector who served as president of the Field Museum and built a large library on Native American subjects, commissioned him to paint portraits of prominent Native American leaders. Newberry finding aids describe the early travels as taking in Oklahoma, New Mexico and Arizona. Ayer’s library became one of the founding collections of the Newberry Library, and Burbank’s papers, drawings and paintings sit within it.
The Newberry describes its Burbank drawings as more than 1,200 red and brown conté crayon portraits on paper, and a related summary of the Ayer collection counts 1,242 drawings and 25 oil paintings by him. Estimates of his total output in other biographies range from nearly 1,000 to more than 1,200 portraits, covering more than 125 tribes, so treat any single figure as approximate. A Newberry digital record dates an oil portrait of the Crow leader Pretty Eagle to 1897. Biographies also say he painted the Apache leader Geronimo more than once, and the Newberry papers include his letters about painting Red Cloud and Chief Joseph.
The plain fact that the project was a commission shapes how it should be read. A patron with a collector’s purpose set the brief, and the sitters appear within a collecting project of the 1890s. A designer borrowing the visual method should keep that context in mind, name the sitters where the records do, and avoid turning them into decorative stock.
Key works you can date and attribute
The list below sticks to works whose date, medium and collection are given in museum or library records.
- Oil portraits of 1898, Art Institute of Chicago. The museum holds eight, titled with the sitters’ names as Tah-Bo-Ho-Ya, Pah-Puh, Shu-Pe-La, Wick-Ah-Te-Wah, Ho-Mo-Vi, Ko-Pe-Ley, Kah-Kap-Tee and Wick-Ey. All are dated 1898. The first three are oil on panel, the others oil on canvas.
- The panels. Tah-Bo-Ho-Ya and Pah-Puh each measure 20.3 by 15.2 centimetres (8 by 6 inches), and Shu-Pe-La 24.1 by 20.3 centimetres. These are portrait-sized studies, not wall paintings.
- Newberry Library, Ayer collection. Hundreds of conté crayon portraits, a smaller group of oils such as the 1897 portrait of Pretty Eagle, and the E. A. Burbank papers, dated 1897 to 1949.
The Art Institute records these eight as a group, purchased with funds provided by Mrs. Herbert A. Vance in honor of James N. Wood. The spread of formats inside one year and one museum group is the first design lesson: Burbank did not use a single frame for everything, but he kept to a small set of sizes.
What to look at in a Burbank portrait
- Crop and scale. The works are small and close, built around the head and shoulders with little room for setting. When you look at the Newberry’s digitised sheets, notice how much of the sheet the face occupies and how little else competes with it.
- Palette. The conté crayon sheets work in red and brown on paper, which is a two-tone system by construction. The oils are described in the museum records only by medium and support, so any colour claims about them should come from looking at the work itself, not from a hex list.
- Inscription. On documentary portraits the sitter’s name, and often a date, belongs on the work. If you study the Newberry digital records, look at how the names are recorded and at the care taken to keep them attached to the face.
Technique: oil study and crayon sheet
The museum records fix the basics. The Art Institute lists the 1898 works as oil on panel and oil on canvas, in small sizes. The Newberry describes the drawings as red and brown conté crayon on paper. Conté crayon is a compressed, pigment-bound drawing material, usually sold in sticks, that allows soft tonal modelling and sharper accents when the stick is turned on its edge.
What the sources do not document is how Burbank moved between the two, for example whether a crayon sheet was a study for an oil or a record in its own right. The useful reading for designers is the pairing. For a designer, the useful point is the pairing itself. A fast sketch format and a finished format can sit in the same system if they share crop, scale and inscription.
How designers can borrow Burbank’s ideas
- Define the series before the pieces. Fix two or three formats, a crop rule and a naming convention, then let the individual images vary within them.
- Crop to the point of interest. If the face, product or headline is the subject, give it most of the frame and keep the background plain.
- Limit the palette to what the medium gives you. A two-tone red and brown system is easy to extend and easy to print. Test your own limited palette with the MGD colour palette generator.
- Keep the name with the image. Credit people by name; build it into the template.
- Know the rules for source images. The Art Institute’s Burbank paintings are not flagged public domain in its data, so use only works that a museum clearly marks as public domain or CC0, as explained in our guide to public domain art.
- Look at the wider tradition. For a contemporary American portraitist working in a more painterly, society-portrait register, compare John Singer Sargent, and for the nineteenth-century movement that valued direct observation, read our overview of realism in art.
Seeing the work in person or online
Two institutions hold the material discussed here. The Art Institute of Chicago’s online collection lists the eight 1898 paintings with their titles, media and sizes. The Newberry Library’s digital collections and finding aids list the drawings, oils and papers within the Edward E. Ayer collection, including the E. A. Burbank papers. Check the rights statement on each record before reusing an image.
Frequently asked questions
Who was Elbridge Ayer Burbank?
An American painter (1858–1949), born in Harvard, Illinois, who studied in Chicago and Munich and who, from 1897, painted portraits of Native American leaders on commission from his uncle Edward E. Ayer.
Where can I see Elbridge Ayer Burbank’s work?
The Newberry Library in Chicago holds the main body, within the Edward E. Ayer collection: drawings, oil paintings and his papers. The Art Institute of Chicago holds eight oil portraits dated 1898.
Are Elbridge Ayer Burbank’s paintings public domain?
The Art Institute of Chicago’s collection data does not flag its Burbank paintings as public domain, so this guide does not reproduce them and does not suggest they are free to use. Check the rights statement of the holding institution before reusing any image.
What can designers learn from Elbridge Ayer Burbank?
How to run a series: a small set of fixed formats, a tight crop on the subject, a limited palette and a name kept with every image. His red and brown crayon sheets and small oil panels show the same idea in two media.



